Quantcast Broadcaster Suspended for Racial Tiger Comment - Golf International Magazine Online
in
Tees2Greens Home Page

Navigate This Blog

Have You Seen This?

Subscribe To This Blog

Golf International Magazine Online

Follow The World... with Golf International Magazine Subscribe Online

Subscribe To This Blog

Broadcaster Suspended for Racial Tiger Comment
Written By: Golf International on Jan 10 2008
Rate This:
Golf Channel suspended anchor Kelly Tilghman for two weeks on Wednesday for saying last week that young players who wanted to challenge Tiger Woods should "lynch him in a back alley."

Tilghman was laughing during the exchange Friday with analyst Nick Faldo at the Mercedes-Benz Championship, and Woods' agent at IMG said he didn't think there was any ill intent.

But the comments became prevalent on news shows Wednesday, and the Rev. Al Sharpton joined the fray by demanding she be fired immediately. Golf Channel didn't know who would replace Tilghman in the booth this week at the Sony Open or next week at the Bob Hope Chrysler Classic.

"There is simply no place on our network for offensive language like this," Golf Channel said in a statement.

Tilghman became golf's first female anchor last year when the PGA Tour signed a 15-year deal in which Golf Channel broadcasts the first three events of the year, weekday coverage of all tour events, and full coverage of the Fall Series and opposite-field events.

The suspension ends in time for the Buick Invitational on Jan. 24, when Woods will make his 2008 debut.

Faldo and Tilghman were discussing young players who could challenge the world's No. 1 player toward the end of Friday's broadcast at Kapalua when Faldo suggested that "to take Tiger on, maybe they should just gang up for a while."

"Lynch him in a back alley," Tilghman replied.

"While we believe that Kelly's choice of words was inadvertent and that she did not intend them in an offensive manner, the words were hurtful and grossly inappropriate," Golf Channel said in its statement. "Consequently, we have decided to suspend Kelly for two weeks, effective immediately."

Woods and Tilghman have known each other 12 years. She was picked to host a club demonstration with Woods in south Florida when he talked about new products from Nike Golf.

Tilghman was helped when Mark Steinberg, Woods' agent at IMG, said it was a non-issue and considered the matter "case closed."

"Tiger and Kelly are friends, and Tiger has a great deal of respect for Kelly," Steinberg said Tuesday night in a statement released by Golf Channel. "Regardless of the choice of words used, we know unequivocally that there was no ill-intent in her comments."

Tilghman had said in a previous statement she apologized directly to Woods, and the immediate support from Woods' camp was critical.

After Woods won the 1997 Masters at age 21 to become its youngest champion, Fuzzy Zoeller referred to him as "that little boy," and suggested that Woods not serve fried chicken or collard greens, "or whatever the hell they serve," at the Champions Dinner.

Woods, who had a different management team in his first full season, did not respond for three days to Zoeller's apology, and it took Zoeller years to recover from the fallout.

Tilghman's comment made the rounds Wednesday on TV shows such as CNN's Headline News, and it was prominently discussed on blogs and message boards on the Internet. It also was a topic on the practice range at the Sony Open.

"I'm sure Kelly wishes she never said that," Jim Furyk said. "I haven't spoken with Tiger, but I've been told that they've had their talk and they've discussed it. Anything I say is kind of just like pouring salt in the wound at this point. Obviously, she would love to not have said that and for it not to be news. I'm glad that her and Tiger spoke."

Fred Funk only heard about the comment Wednesday morning.

"There was no ill intent at all," he said. "I think it was just a slip, and they said that Tiger has already forgiven her. I think when you're in the TV tower for that many hours, you're going to wish you didn't say some things probably, and that was one thing that slipped out. I think you've got to give them a little grace.

"Her integrity, how Kelly is respected out here, is pretty good. I think Tiger really likes Kelly, so that helped squash it. Because Tiger could have run off with that if he took it the wrong way. But he didn't, so that was good."

Before her suspension was announced, Sharpton spoke earlier on CNN's "Prime News" and continued to push for her firing, saying he wanted to meet with Golf Channel because the comments were "an insult to all blacks."

"Lynching is not murder in general, it's not assault in general," Sharpton said. "It's a specific racial term that this women should be held accountable for. What she said is racist. Whether she's a racist ... is immaterial. She's a broadcaster. The channel has to be accountable to the public."



Add to Technorati Favorites

Comments

 

doubleegolf said:

I think the Rev Al should mind his own business and make sure he gets his past years W2 forms into the IRS. I'd love to know where he gets his money from. I hope they investigate him from now till doomsday. BY THE WAY, I never hear anything about the Tawana Brawley case in upstate NY. That was a pack of lies, but nothing happened there!

Go back to your church and pray .

January 11, 2008 6:31 AM
 

Jaap Groen said:

As a surviver from the nazi concentration camps Auschwitz, Mauthausen and Ebensee, I can't let this just go by without commenting on this sick remark.

In this world filled with hate and envy, we have the opportunity to use our communication systems such as TV ,radio and the printed press to restore the lost positive position my country, the USA has enjoyed for many decades. This remark took me back to 12940-1945 . These were the expressions the Germans were using for us Jews. I am originally from Holland and now  a proud American citizen for 52 years. Jaap Groen

January 11, 2008 7:10 AM
 

rebel1216 said:

I don't for one second believe Kelly Tilghman meant anything other than beating Tiger was a formidable task and would require something drastic.  I think everyone should lighten up and take her comment in the spirit in which it was intended.  Kelly is an outstanding commentator and a true professional.  If Tiger isn't upset about it, why should anyone else get involved.  Al Shapton is just grabbing one more opportunity to get some headlines.  He offends me almost every time he speaks.  While I think suspending Kelly was the "politically correct" thing to do, I also believe that morally she deserved no punishment.  Everybody needs to take a chill pill and worry about things that really matter like world hunger and war.  

January 11, 2008 7:14 AM
 

RJE1959 said:

I think Rev Al Sharpton should take a step back and realize that a comment made in jest, is just that. Kelly did not mean anything racial, she clearly was jokingly pointing out that for young players to overtake Tiger's position in the rankings would require that he basically not be golfing anymore.  And at his age, he isn't giving up the game on his own. Poor judgement on her choice of words? Definitely! Malice intent, no way.

January 11, 2008 7:33 AM
 

forthefew said:

The use of the word "lynch" was her downfall.  We all know what she meant.  It's what was <i>implied</i> by using that specific word that's the problem. She could have just as easily said, "Beat him in a back alley."  But she didn't.  She's racists; and deserves to have a big R painted on her forehead for at least a few weeks.

January 11, 2008 7:48 AM
 

Blkgent52 said:

The young lady should look at the movie 'The Great Debaters' and then think of the word she chose to use. I am not a big Al Sharpton fan, but there have been many instances that he has been involved in and he has been correct; like in this case. Tiger may blow it off and they may be friends; but that is not an excuse for the term and forum in which the term was used. Insulting is being kind here because of the term used. Should she be fired? Left up to me, yes.

January 11, 2008 8:24 AM
 

end2game said:

The fact that Al Sharpton has come into this as a "defender of the faith" reminds me of a discussion group I was in about the "bible"! I remarked that in a class in school about the "facts" in the bible the professor remarked  "remember back in those days as in these days" they were great story tellers! And some of the wording was probably for  dramatric purposes. Not to be taken literally!  This followed by another in the group that JUMPED me and said "if I don't believe in every word in the bible then I have issues that I need to address"! At whch point the moderator reminded her that SHE could not push her beliefs on another or it would be as a dictator!

How could Sharpton know what was in Kelly's mind? And again HE is pushing HIS beliefs on everyone!  The old "or else" thing!  I have seen Tiger and Kelly on the Golf Channel many times and believe they ARE close. Just as close as Mark C. And Mark O' and many of Tigers close friends. And I'm sure they talk of many thngs that someone outside of their circle would not understand as normal for them.

She has been suspended and I think it should be enough and I am willing to bet that Tiger and the others tha know Kelly aren't happy even with the suspension!

Oh ya, Mr Al, Throw the first stone.....................I think someone famous said that once!!!

January 11, 2008 8:56 AM
 

TURKO said:

Hey Endgame, it's not like I don't agree with you, but obviously Kelly did have much going through her head making that comment.   You know...I'm not the biggest Al Sharpton fan either, but that comment was pretty insensitive.  Even if she and Tiger are friends, it's still not something you want to say on a television broadcast.  Moreover, the probelm I have with Sharpton is that if Kelly's comment was anit-semetic he wouldn't have gotten involved.  

January 11, 2008 9:16 AM
 

forthefew said:

[RE: If Kelly's comment was anit-semetic he wouldn't have gotten involved.]  Damned good point, TURKO!

January 11, 2008 9:26 AM
 

end2game said:

[RE: If Kelly's comment was anit-semetic he wouldn't have gotten involved.]  Damned good point, TURKO!

Ok guys, I see now. Kelly is suppose to be a racist and Mr AL, "opps" Reverand Al is a Biggot?

Sound like I don't need to work on him then................

January 11, 2008 9:56 AM
 

AllforGolf said:

I'm shocked they did not sensor her remarks; give me a frkin break.

What has this world come to?????

Not even the Golf Channel is amuned to over-zealous, over-sensitive, over-bearing critizing people who probably do not know the difference between a Mulligan and the 19th hole if they were given a Dictionary or Bible; not that either reference would improve the game of Golf....Oh that's right, I forgot, Kelly was talking about the game of GOLF....DAM...please sensor that last reference.

And by the way; it is referred to as HUMOR...not slander

January 11, 2008 9:58 AM
 

forthefew said:

Wow.  Check out Happy G's comment here: www.tees2greens.com/.../2479.aspx

I'm almost speachless.

January 11, 2008 10:11 AM
 

somerssalt said:

The essential question here is: Is lynching necessarily racial?

Asked another way, would Kelly Tilghman have used the word ‘lynching’ if she were instead referring to a dominant Caucasian golfer?

I always thought the word ‘hanging’ and ‘lynching’ were interchangeable, but I’m certainly no expert so I looked in the dictionary. It said: “To put to death by mob action without legal sanction”.

Then I searched the internet. Wikipedia states: “The term 'lynching' is believed to have originated during the American Revolution when Charles Lynch, a Virginia justice of the peace, ordered extralegal punishment for Tory Acts”. It goes on to say: “Records of lynchings between the years 1880 and 1951 show 3437 African-American victims, as well as 1293 white victims…”.

Looking further, I found multiple references to lynching that have nothing to do with African Americans. For example: “Three Mexican undercover federal agents doing a narcotics investigation were lynched in the town of San Juan Ixtayopan, Mexico City, by an angry crowd who saw them taking photographs and mistakenly suspected they were trying to abduct children from a primary school.”

I also learned that ‘lynchings’ were common in Great Britain and totally unrelated to race.

Kelly Tilghman used the word lynching quite correctly: The only hope a group of young aspiring golfers would have of defeating Tiger is to lynch him (put him to death by mob action without legal sanction).

An innocent person’s career is being “lynched”, and this attack IS racially motivated. The people reading racial innuendo into her obviously innocent remark are the ones demonstrating their preoccupation with race, not her. Like the majority of us, race probably rarely ever crosses her mind.

True racial acceptance is when race does not even enter into one’s consciousness, and Al Sharpton proves yet again that he is one of the most racially-biased people in America. He is all-consumed with racial hatred.

January 11, 2008 10:31 AM
 

end2game said:

somerssalt said:

The essential question here is: Is lynching necessarily racial?

forthefew said:

Wow.  Check out Happy G's comment here: www.tees2greens.com/.../2479.aspx

I'm almost speachless.

I think both these are fantastic(showing my age now). And I think these and Happy G's should be sent to the Golf Channel and Tiger and every PGA pro out their for some sort of support for the 'game" and humanity. Plus I hope "my hero" Tiger (even though he's more than 25 years my junior) reads these things. And knows we all support him and the things that happened at the Ryder Cup and goes public for his friends!!!

January 11, 2008 11:05 AM
 

Breeze said:

Somerssalt said it best and even did a little research. By the way, some of you who comment would be taken more seriously if you could spell !!!

January 11, 2008 4:14 PM
 

withthewind said:

I agree somerssalt said it the best.  I can't believe we have succeeded in allowing this to fall to this level.   I think the "Sharptons" of this world should take on the "Comedy Channel," now that's offensive...and they intend it to be so.  I am appalled at what is being done to Kelly's career and reputation over something this ignorant.  

January 11, 2008 5:41 PM
 

forthefew said:

WTF?!?!?!  Naaaah.  The word lynch isn't a racially charged word.  Naaaaaaaaah.....

sports.espn.go.com/.../story

January 18, 2008 10:26 AM
 

mrjuiceman said:

My' O' My',  A white person used the L word!!  Al Sharpton is back in business. Kelly and Tiger are friends, why in the world would she intentionally say something that would be offensive to Tiger and the Golf channel audience?  Don Imes  YES!!   We need to lighten up and know the difference between hate and a simple mistake. I"m sure Rev Sharpton that at least one of your friends has used the N word when talking to you. Did you campaign for them too be Fired??  I think not,!!!   When the situation calls for it I say let them have. Choose the battles that matter!

January 23, 2008 11:19 PM

About Golf International

Follow The World... with Golf International Magazine

Subscribe Online

Since its launch in 1997, Golf International has forged a reputation as the standout quality title in golf publishing. The caliber of columnists, writers, players and coaches is unrivalled, while the design and layout of the magazine separates it still further from the competition. In a congested market wrought with mediocrity, Golf International appeals to committed golfers who are as serious about their game as we are about ours.

The ethos behind Golf International is simple: our aim is to entertain, inform and educate our readers with a wide range of fresh and original editorial. Peter Alliss, Ian Wooldridge, Colin Callander, Tom Cox, Paul Mahoney, Clive Agran and John Huggan are listed among our regular columnists. Other notable contributors include Paul Trow and David Davies. We are particularly proud of our association with the teaching staff of the DLGA, who, under the guidance of the world’s No.1 coach – David Leadbetter – provide some of the finest instruction you will find anywhere. Monty’s coach, Denis Pugh, is another regular contributor, as is leading European Tour coach, Peter Cowen, and one of the world’s most innovative instructors, Robert Baker. The popular Senior Tour player, Tony Johnstone, has also made Golf International his literary home.

With the generous and on-going support of Volvo Car UK, we are committed to developing our Amateur pages, featuring regular profiles, interviews and tournament news from both the men’s and women’s amateur game. Another innovation has been our Business pages, which provide the magazine with a unique angle on business-related stories, along with regular features from our resident experts on golfing memorabilia (Kevin McGimpsey), betting (Jeremy Chapman) and motoring (Anthony ffrench-Constant). We hope you enjoy the magazine and invite you to be a part of our continued success.

With a new distribution partner – Comag – in place from the August ’06 issue (and already delivering a significant increase in newsstand sales), we will be raising our game in the retail sector while at the same time consolidating our position as the premium title in the air and selected-sponsorship sectors.

Privacy Policy | Legal Statement | Advertise
© 2006-2008 Tees2Greens, Inc.